In
Judy Brady’s “I Want a Wife” Brady discusses what exactly it means to be a
wife. She discusses every aspect of the life of a wife/mother. She does so by
using repetition of the phrase “I want a wife…” and personifying herself as a
spouse of the wife. I believe her intended audience is anyone who underestimates
the demandingness of being a wife. Specifically, I believe the targeted audience
would be spouses of a wife due to the tone and nature of the writing.
In
Christina Sommers’ “Men—It’s in Their Nature” she talks about how males are
different from females. It started off when her son went to camping in the
Negev Desert. Some counselors had done an experiment with the campers where
they all went off on their own and wrote about what they felt. Not to Sommers’s
surprise, the boys did not comply with the counselors and instead decided that building
a fire with the materials provided would be better. Sommers then provides
information that more studies have shown that there is a biological difference
in the way that men and women behave and perceive certain things. Lastly, she
talks about how men are not recognized as crucial pieces in our society. Women
are glamorized for their poetry that expresses their feelings and yet men are
undermined in their abilities that accentuates their masculinity such as construction
and civil service.
I will
be choosing the second essay (Sommers) for my analytical essay. The reason
being is I believe it will be better to write about because it has more all-around
evidence as opposed to Brady’s essay that was mostly just emotion behind it.
I commented on Britainy's Blog and Joshua's Blog
I commented on Britainy's Blog and Joshua's Blog
Good job. I think you did an excellent job of summarizing each of the author's key points and explaining what their purpose(s) are. I think you have chosen a decent essay to focus on. Be sure to leave the personal bias and opinions to the side and really hone in on the evidence that makes the piece strong, as you work on the analysis draft.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAlthough I agree that Judy Brady's piece involved a great deal of emotion, It's hard to deny that her stance on gender equality was fueled by fact. I think anyone choosing Judy's essay would be able to find substantial evidence through outside sources to support her claims on the life of a 1970's housewife. I thought her emotion is what makes the piece so powerful. Nice job on your summaries!
ReplyDelete